A new agreement between the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman (PHSO) and NHS Resolution raises an interesting question for those involved in clinical negligence claims: could complaints and claims provide a more useful picture when considered together?
The two organisations announced a Memorandum of Understanding in August, committing to closer collaboration and greater sharing of information over the coming year. Both hold considerable information about where things go wrong within NHS care, but from different perspectives.
The PHSO sees complaints from patients and families, while NHS Resolution has extensive data and experience arising from clinical negligence claims.
Significantly, the organisations themselves recognise the potential connection. In announcing the agreement, they noted that an increase in complaints could signal an increase in future claims – and vice versa.
What Can Complaints Tell Us Before Claims Arise?
A complaint and a clinical negligence claim serve different purposes. A complaint may seek an explanation, acknowledgement or action following concerns about care, while a negligence claim requires consideration of breach of duty, causation and loss. The complaints process may provide an earlier indication of claims developing or increasing in a certain area.
But The Underlying Circumstances Can Overlap.
Repeated complaints about similar aspects of treatment, communication, diagnosis or escalation may provide an early indication of problems which subsequently feature in clinical negligence claims.
For claimant solicitors, the complaints process can also form part of the history preceding a claim. What was raised, how concerns were investigated and what information was provided may all contribute to understanding what happened.
What Can Claims Tell Us?
The relationship works in the other direction too. Clinical negligence claims generate detailed information about adverse outcomes and the circumstances surrounding them. NHS Resolution describes its claims data and insight as an important means of learning from harm and improving patient safety.
The question raised by the new agreement is whether looking more closely across complaints and claims could help identify recurring problems earlier.
One complaint or one claim may concern an individual set of circumstances. A pattern across a number of them could tell a different story.
Sharing Information More Effectively
The PHSO and NHS Resolution say their closer collaboration should provide stronger evidence about areas of safety concern, help prevent future failures in care and improve planning for future demand.
There are also practical aims, including clearer signposting between the two organisations and better communication where both are investigating matters relating to the same case.
For those working with clinical negligence claims, the interesting aspect will be what happens when the information is brought together. Identifying a pattern is one thing; using that information to reduce the likelihood of the same problem recurring is another.
A Claims Perspective
Claimant clinical negligence solicitors see the consequences when failures in care result in avoidable harm. Complaints may provide an earlier indication of some of the circumstances that ultimately lead to claims, while claims themselves provide detailed evidence of where and why harm has occurred.
Closer information sharing between the PHSO and NHS Resolution therefore seems a logical development. The real test will be whether joining those dots leads not only to a better understanding of recurring problems, but to action that helps prevent similar harm – and the claims that can follow.
Sources and further reading: This article draws on the August 2026 Memorandum of Understanding between NHS Resolution and the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, together with NHS Resolution’s 2026/27 Business Plan and published information on the NHS complaints process.
The Temple Perspective
The closer link between complaints and claims is a positive and sensible development, provided it leads to practical learning rather than simply more data being collected.
In our experience, clinical negligence claims rarely arise in isolation. They often follow a period where patients or families have already raised concerns, sought explanations, or felt that communication has broken down.
For those of us involved in ATE insurance and clinical negligence underwriting, early indicators matter. Patterns in complaints may help identify areas where risk is emerging before that risk is fully reflected in claims volumes or claims cost.
That does not mean every complaint will become a claim, or that complaints data should be treated as a direct predictor of liability. But where repeated themes appear – for example around diagnosis, escalation, consent, communication, or delays in treatment – they can provide useful context for understanding future claims trends.
The important point is how the information is used. If complaints and claims data are considered together, they may help NHS organisations, claimant representatives and insurers better understand where avoidable harm is occurring, where communication is failing, and where earlier intervention could make a difference. That should be welcomed.
For Temple, the value of this type of collaboration is not just in forecasting future claims activity. It is in improving the quality of decision-making across the process. Better information can help all parties assess risk more realistically, resolve appropriate claims more efficiently, and support a system that learns from recurring problems rather than dealing with them only once litigation has started.
Matthew Best
Director - ATE Partnerships
By Matthew Best
19 Nov, 2026